Recipes:  Homemade Tomato Sauce and Peperonata

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Recipes:  Homemade Tomato Sauce and PeperonataFresh local tomatoes and peppers are in abundance and reasonably priced, so it’s a perfect time to whip up Arthur Schwartz’s recipes for homemade tomato sauce and a little Peperonata as an antipasto.

Roasted Tomatoes (and Sauce)

Recipes:  Homemade Tomato Sauce and PeperonataMakes enough sauce for 1 pound of spaghetti or macaroni

Print This Post Print This Post

This is one of my favorite summer recipes. Use it when the tomatoes are really abundant and inexpensive, and when you’ve tired of eating them in salads, sandwiches and for their own sake. The only problem with this as a summer recipe is that you must have the oven on for at least two hours. So bake the tomatoes in the cool of morning. I’ve even tossed them with the spaghetti early in the day, then eaten the dish at room temperature in the evening. If you’re Italian, you may cringe at the thought of tepid pasta, but if you grew up, as I did, eating leftover sauced macaroni direct from the refrigerator, then this won’t seem strange at all.

  • 5-6 medium very ripe tomatoes (about 2 pounds)
  • Salt and freshly ground black pepper to taste
  • 2-3 large cloves garlic, finely chopped
  • 1/3 cup fruity olive oil
  • 8-10 large fresh basil leaves, shredded or snipped
  1. With the tip of a small knife, cut out tomato cores. Halve tomatoes crosswise. Coat bottom of a roasting pan or baking dish (I use an attractive oval Pyrex pan, available at most houseware departments) with about 2 tablespoons oil. Arrange tomato halves, cut side up, in pan. Sprinkle with salt and pepper. Press minced garlic into each half; drizzle each with about 1 teaspoon oil. Pour on any remaining oil.
  2. Place tomatoes in a preheated 375-degree oven and cook 2 hours, basting two or three times with the oil and juices that collect in pan. When done, tomatoes will have collapsed and some of the juices will have burned a little.
  3. With a table knife and fork, cut tomatoes into small pieces. Scrape burned bits into juices to amalgamate them into sauce.
  4. Toss in cooked spaghetti and shredded basil. Taste for salt and pepper. I add a lot of black pepper or have red pepper flakes or ground red pepper for everyone to add to their taste at the table.
  5. Serve immediately with grated cheese, if desired, though I personally don’t find it necessary.

Note: this freezes nicely.


Recipes:  Homemade Tomato Sauce and PeperonataMakes about 1 quart

Print This Post Print This Post

Serve Peperonata as an antipasto — with bread to mop up the juices — on toasted bread as a bruschetta topping, as a side dish to meat, poultry, fish or scrambled eggs, on macaroni as a sauce, or with cheese and other vegetables as a vegetarian meal.

  • 3 medium onions (about 1 pound)
  • 1/4 cup extra-virgin olive oil
  • 5 or 6 large sweet red peppers (or mixed red, yellow, and orange) (about 3 pounds)
  • 5 or 6 plum tomatoes (about 1 pound), peeled if desired
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
  • Freshly ground black pepper
  • 1/4 cup finely chopped basil

Peel onions. Cut in half through the root end and slice thinly crosswise.

In a large pot with a cover, combine the onions and olive oil. Cook the onions over medium heat, stirring occasionally, until they are soft but not colored.

Meanwhile, prepare the peppers: Wash them. With a paring knife, cut them in half, then remove the cores, ribs and seeds. With a large knife, cut them lengthwise into 1/4-inch- to 1/2-inch-wide strips. You don’t have to be exact.

By the time the peppers are prepared, the onions should be soft. Add the peppers and mix well with the onions. Cook the peppers while preparing the tomatoes, about 5 minutes or so, stirring them a couple of times.

With the tip of a paring knife, cut out tomato cores. Cut tomatoes in half lengthwise, then each half again lengthwise, then into 6 to 8 pieces crosswise.

Add the tomatoes to the onions and peppers. Season with salt. Cover the pot and let simmer at a perky pace for about 20 minutes, stirring a couple of times with a wooden spoon.

When done, the peppers should be wilted but still with a tiny snap. Taste to check. They’ll continue to soften as they cool.

If necessary, because there is too much liquid, uncover the pot for the second half of the cooking time. The peperonata should not be too soupy. The liquid should have a saucy consistency.

Stir in basil for last 2 or 3 minutes of cooking. Season to taste with freshly ground pepper – a few turns of the peppermill should be enough.

Serve hot, at room temperature, or cool, but not cold.

Note: It is not necessary to peel the tomatoes for this recipe – that is, if you don’t mind tomato skins. Some people feel they are unsightly or indigestible. To peel a tomato, place in boiling water for 60 seconds. Remove and let cool enough to handle. Cut a slit in skin near core. Skin should pull right off. If it doesn’t, forget it and don’t worry about it.

sign up box


  • Arthur Schwartz

    About Arthur: The New York Times Magazine called Arthur Schwartz “a walking Google of food and restaurant knowledge.” As the restaurant critic and executive food editor of the New York Daily News, which he was for 18 years, he was called The Schwartz Who Ate New York. Nowadays, he is best known as The Food Maven, the name of his website. Whatever the sobriquet, he is acknowledged as one of the country’s foremost experts on food, cooking, culinary history, restaurants, and restaurant history. Visit Arthur At:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.