Spotlight: Long Island Ice Cream Spots

“Cool Down & Connect: Ice Cream Spots with a Side of Nostalgia” 

 Some of the sweetest moments of summer come in a cone. Whether it’s the taste of your childhood or the joy of treating your grandkids, Long Island is home to some truly special ice cream spots—places where every scoop feels like a step back in time. These local gems aren’t just about dessert; they’re about memories, tradition, and connection. 

 Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe – Riverhead 

Nestled in Riverhead since 1953, Snowflake Ice Cream Shoppe is the kind of roadside stand that makes you feel like summer never ended. Known for its old-school charm and homemade flavors, it has become a treasured stop for locals and visitors alike. Their signature creation—the “Peconic Swamp Thing,” a decadent blend of fudge, cookies, and rich chocolate ice cream—has earned legendary status. Whether you’re craving a classic cone or a creative sundae, the friendly staff and nostalgic vibe make it a must-visit on the East End. www.snowflakeicecream.com 

Coyle’s Ice Cream – Bay Shore 

Walking into Coyle’s is like stepping into a Norman Rockwell painting. With its red leather booths, checkered floors, and 1950s-style soda fountain, this Bay Shore institution has been delighting families for decades. Offering more than 50 hand-dipped flavors—from Butter Pecan to Cookie Monster—it’s the kind of place where kids press their noses to the glass and grandparents smile knowingly, remembering their own childhood favorites. The portions are generous, the atmosphere is cheerful, and the memories? They’re made to last. www.coylesicecream.com 




Marvel Frozen Dairy – Lido Beach 

Just a short stroll from the boardwalk, Marvel Frozen Dairy has been a summer staple since the 1950s. This soft-serve stand has earned a loyal following thanks to its classic twist cones, thick milkshakes, and nostalgic beach-town feel. After a long day in the sun, there’s nothing better than standing in line barefoot in your flip-flops, debating between chocolate, vanilla, or both. Take your cone to-go and catch a seaside sunset—it’s the kind of simple joy that stays with you. www.marvelfrozendairy.com 

 Five Pennies Creamery – Rockville Centre 

 

Named after the Danny Kaye film “The Five Pennies,” this whimsical creamery is a colorful celebration of ice cream and imagination. Located in the heart of Rockville Centre, it’s a favorite for families and date nights alike. With over 130 rotating flavors and a menu full of playful sundaes, it’s hard to choose just one—but that’s part of the fun. The interior is delightfully retro, and the atmosphere is as warm as a summer evening. If you’re lucky, you might even catch a sing-along or a nostalgic tune playing in the background. www.fivepenniescreameryny.com 

 So go ahead—take a little detour, cool down, and reconnect. Because some of life’s most unforgettable moments start with, “Want to go out for ice cream?” 

 

Andrea Peponakis

Andrea Peponakis is a retired foreign language teacher who then became a local newspaper journalist and local radio show host. Born and raised in Astoria, Queens and on Long Island, Andrea is now focusing on writing children’s books. The motivation to become an author was inspired by her three grandchildren. Her book, Grandma, Grandma, Tell Me More: My Family Loves Me, was featured at this year’s London Book Festival and at The LA Times Book Fair. Andrea currently resides on Long Island near her children and grandchildren. Her days are spent creating everlasting memories with her grandchildren and writing.

Andrea Peponakis

Andrea Peponakis is a retired foreign language teacher who then became a local newspaper journalist and local radio show host. Born and raised in Astoria, Queens and on Long Island, Andrea is now focusing on writing children’s books. The motivation to become an author was inspired by her three grandchildren. Her book, Grandma, Grandma, Tell Me More: My Family Loves Me, was featured at this year’s London Book Festival and at The LA Times Book Fair. Andrea currently resides on Long Island near her children and grandchildren. Her days are spent creating everlasting memories with her grandchildren and writing.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.